American Idol 5 Top 12 Girls

Based on their performances this week, my ranking of the 12 girls is as follows:


1/2 Lisa Tucker - perfect performace


1/2 Katharine McPhee - excellent


3 Mandisa - very good but her vocal prowess isn't as strong as Lisa's and Katharine's


4 Paris Bennett - undeniably good but IMHO, she over performed and was too jumpy/perky


5 Kinnik Sky - good but lacks charisma


6 Ayla Brown - very good choice of song but has limited abilities

7 Melissa McGhee - good but also lacks charisma

8 Kellie Pickler - picked the wrong song but still good

9 Brenna Getthers - big personality, not so big talent

10 Becky O' Donahue - shaky performance, was obviously nervous, but could probably do better if she survives this week

11 Heather Cox - shaky and forgettable

12 Stevie Scott - only her smile and pretty face could probably save her this week